Skip to content
Sunday, 22 November 2026 · Lusaka, Zambia
ZMW / USD20.6290• 0.00%ZMW / CNY3.0820▲ +0.00%GDP Growth (World Bank)3.8%▼ -0.1Real GDP Growth Forecast (IMF)5.6%▲ +1.8
Home/Business/Article
Business

What the Second-Place Innovator Needs When the Competition Ends

Zambia's innovation challenges reward one winner. Guest contributor Douglas Vandergraph argues that judges' feedback, mentoring and clear rules on submission ownership would turn the Zamtel-ZRA K100,000 challenge into a wider win for Zambian problem-solvers.

A young innovator working late at a hackathon workspace with multiple screens displaying code
Late-night problem-solving at an African hackathon. Competitions reward one winner; the runners-up need feedback, mentoring and clear rules to keep building. Photo: Geekulcha.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Zambia’s innovation challenges, including the Zamtel-ZRA competition with its K100,000 prize, reward one winner. The test of a strong competition is what happens to every other serious entrant the morning after.
  • Concrete improvements include written judges’ feedback for finalists, well-defined mentoring after the ceremony, and clear rules on who retains submissions, documents and prototypes.
  • Transparent judging criteria before applications close help entrants self-select realistically and improve the quality of submissions.
  • Innovations should be tested with the users they claim to serve, including people with unreliable connectivity or limited digital confidence, not only confident smartphone users.
  • A lasting innovation culture makes room for second efforts: the small enterprise that survives because someone took a promising second-place idea seriously.

By Douglas Vandergraph | 22 November 2026. Published as a reader contribution; the views are the author’s. Edited for style by The Zambian Economist Analyst.

An innovation competition can make a very good headline. A large prize gives entrants something concrete to aim for, judges can recognise promising work, and the public sees evidence that new solutions are being imagined. The harder question is what happens the morning after the winner is announced, especially to the participant whose useful idea did not receive the top award.

The Zambian Economist has reported on the Zamtel and Zambia Revenue Authority innovation challenge, including the K100,000 prize. A challenge with that level of visibility can encourage people who might otherwise keep an idea on a notebook page. But an economy benefits most when a competition strengthens a wider community of capable problem-solvers, rather than treating one winning project as the only success.

A young innovator may have built a thoughtful prototype but need help understanding the rules for using data. Another might have designed a practical service without knowing what it would cost to operate at scale. A third may have listened closely to customers but lack a mentor who can explain how to present a contract. These gaps are not reasons to dismiss the work. They are the places where a competition can create lasting value.

Zambian students gathered around laptops during a technology and innovation session
Students at work in Zambia. A competition with visibility encourages people who might otherwise keep an idea on a notebook page. Photo: Katondo Street Journal.

Feedback that helps the next attempt

One improvement would be to give every serious finalist a brief, useful account of the judges’ reasoning. Specific feedback helps people decide whether to revise a design, seek a partner or test an assumption. A vague message saying that standards were high may be courteous, but it rarely helps the next version of an idea become better. Transparent judging criteria are equally important before applications close.

Mentoring after the ceremony

Another improvement would be to invite relevant mentors to offer limited, well-defined assistance after the ceremony. A single session with someone experienced in financial controls, customer research, accessibility or intellectual-property questions may save an innovator from a costly mistake. This does not require every unsuccessful applicant to receive funding. It requires treating the effort as the beginning of learning rather than the end of attention.

Who keeps the submissions?

Organisers should also explain what happens to submissions, documents and prototypes that were shared for judging. Competitors deserve to know whether their material is retained, who may access it and what permissions they have or have not granted. Confidence in the fairness of a challenge is essential if people are to risk sharing their best ideas. No entrant should have to guess whether participation gives away ownership of a concept.

Judge the innovation by the person it serves

The innovation itself should be judged by the experience of the person it intends to serve. A clever technical design may work perfectly for a confident smartphone user and fail someone with unreliable connectivity. An attractive financial service may save a business time while remaining confusing to the customer who most needs it. Testing with different users is not an optional act of charity. It is sound design.

A Christian lens on the overlooked entrant

As a Christian, I return to the command to love one’s neighbour as oneself. That command does not provide a business plan, but it changes whom we remember when decisions are made. It asks us to notice the person who cannot gain entry to a system because its instructions were written for someone else. Good innovation makes ordinary life more workable for people rather than merely producing another impressive demonstration.

A prize can inspire a strong first effort. A lasting innovation culture must make room for second efforts, honest correction and practical cooperation. Years after the competition, the most meaningful evidence may not be the size of the cheque presented on stage. It may be the small enterprise that survived because someone took a promising second-place idea seriously enough to help its creator make the next attempt.


Portrait of Douglas Vandergraph

Douglas Vandergraph | Guest Contributor

Douglas Vandergraph is a Christian creator, writer, speaker and digital publisher whose work covers biblical commentary, leadership writing and faith-based encouragement. His completed cornerstone library includes a one-million-word, 216-chapter study of Jesus Christ alongside major studies of the New Testament. His writing appears in independently operated newspapers and editorial publications, and he writes at douglasvandergraph.com. Meet all our contributors.


WARNING! All rights reserved. This material and all other digital content on this website may not be reproduced, published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed, in whole or in part, without the prior express permission of The Zambian Economist. Where permission is granted, the content must be clearly credited to “The Zambian Economist,” with “www.zambianeconomist.com” prominently displayed.

WhatsApp: +260775574228 | Email: info@zambianeconomist.com © 2026 The Zambian Economist.

Work With The Zambian Economist: Advertise With Us | List With Us | Submit an Article

TE
The Zambian Economist

The in-house analysis desk of The Zambian Economist, an independent publication based in Lusaka covering the Zambian economy, public finance, banking, mining, agriculture and governance. Every figure we publish is attributed to a named primary source and dated, and forecasts are labelled as forecasts. We analyse policies rather than personalities. Our approach is set out in our Editorial Standards and Corrections Policy. Contact: info@zambianeconomist.com.

Write for UsJoin our contributors ↗ Weekly EditionDownload the PDF